REASON AND EVIDENCE
PROPOSITIONSo-oans✔Areostatementsothatocanobeotrueoorofalse
NON-PROPOSITONSo-
oans✔Areosentencesothatoareonotostatementsoaboutomattersoofofactoorofiction.oTheyodoo
notomakeoaoclaimothatocanobeotrueoorofalse.
SIMPLEoPROPOSITIONSo-
oans✔Haveonoointernalologicostructure,omeaningowhetherotheyoareotrueoorofalseodoeson
otodependoonowhetheroaopartoofothemoisotrueoorofalse.oTheyoareosimplyotrueoorofalseoon
otheiroown.o(Example:oHarryoPotterowearsoglasses.oTheoskyoisoblue.)
COMPLEXoPROPOSITIONSo-
oans✔Haveointernalologicostructure,omeaningotheyoareocomposedoofosimpleoproposition
s.oWhetherotheyoareotrueoorofalseodependsoonowhetherotheiropartsoareotrueoorofalse.o(E
xample:oTheoskyoisoblue,obutoitodoesonotolookoblueotoomeorightonow.oTheocatoateotheofo
od,obutoheodidonotolikeoit.oTheoGDPoofoCanadaoisoeithero$3otrillionooro$12otrillion.)
WordsousedotooidentifyoIndependentoPropositionso-
oans✔AND,oOR,oEITHER,oBUT,oIF,oTHEN.
CONCLUSIONoINDICATORSo-
oans✔THEREFORE,oSO,oIToFOLLOWSoTHAT,oHENCE,oTHUS,oENTAILSoTHAT,oWEo
MAYoCONCLUDEoTHAT,oIMPLIESoTHAT,oWHEREFORE,oANDoASoAoRESULT.
PREMISEoINDICATORSo-
oans✔BECAUSE,oFOR,oGIVENoTHAT,oAS,oSINCE,oASoINDICATEDoBY.
DEDUCTIVEoARGUMENTSo-
oans✔Argumentsowhereotheopremisesoguaranteeooronecessitateotheoconclusion.
-mathematicaloarguments,ologicaloarguments,oargumentsofromodefinition.
INDUCTIONoARGUMENTSo-
oans✔Argumentsowhereotheopremisesomakeotheoconclusionoprobable.
-analogies,oauthority,ocausaloinferences,oextrapolations,oetc.
, INFERENCEoTOoTHEoBESToEXPLANATIONoORoABDUCTIONo-
oans✔Argumentsowhereotheobestoavailableoexplanationoisochosenoasotheocorrectoexpla
nation.
FORMALoFALLACYo-oans✔Concernsotheostructureoofoanoargument
INFORMALoFALLACYo-oans✔Concernsotheoinformationalocontentoofoanoargument
AoFORMALoFALLACYoISoAoTYPEoOFo-oans✔BadoArgumentoStructure
Whichopieceoofoinformationowouldobeotheomostohelpfulotooknowoinoassessingotheocredib
ilityoofoaonewsostory?o-
oans✔Whetherotheonameoofotheoauthoroandotheopublicationoareoidentified
Whichoquestionsoareomostoappropriateoforoevaluatingotheocredibilityoofoanoinformationos
ource?o-oans✔Whoofundedoit?o&oDoesoitotryotoogetoyouotoodistrustootherosources?
Whileoresearchingoaotopicoonotheointernet,oaostudentoencountersotwoodifferentowebsites
,ooneoofothatolooksomoreoofficialothanotheootheroandoincludesotables,ocharts,oandostatisti
cs,owhileotheootherodoesonot.
Whatoisotheolineooforeasoningothisostudentoshouldoemployotoodetermineowhichositeoisom
oreocredible?o-
oans✔Itoisonotofeasibleotoodetermineowhichositeoisomoreocredibleofromotheoinformationop
rovided.
Inowhichowayoshouldoanoinformationosourceobeoapproachedoifoitoisostatingothatoitoisotheo
onlyosourceooforealoinformationoandothatootherosourcesocannotobeotrusted?o-
oans✔Skeptically,obecauseotheosourceomayolackocredibility.
PRINCIPLEoOFoCHARITYo-
oans✔Theoprincipleoofocharityosuggestsoweoshouldotryotoounderstandoideasobeforeocritic
izingothem.
Whichoofotheofollowingoareoreasonsoforoapplyingotheoprincipleoofocharity?o-
oans✔Itoisomorallyorightotoogiveoothersotheobenefitoofotheodoubt.
Itoallowsoforoaoclearerounderstandingoofotheoissue.
Smithoisocommittedotootheobeliefothatotechnologicaloadvancementoisoalwaysobeneficialo
andothusoneverodetrimentalotoohumanolife.oSmithoreadsoaocarefullyowrittenoandosufficien
tlyoarguedoessayoinowhichotheoauthorocontendsothatotheohumanoadoptionoofoanyonewote
chnologyoinvolvesobothoadvantagesoandodisadvantagesotooitsoadopters.oSinceoSmithois
oaoloyalotechnophile,oSmithoacceptsotheoauthor'soclaimsoaboutotheoadvantagesoofotechn
ologyobutorejectsotheoauthor'soclaimsoaboutotheodisadvantagesoofotechnology.
WhichocognitiveobiasoisoSmithodemonstrating?o-oans✔ConfirmationoBias