Leadership vs Management
Leaders: The art of getting work done through others willingly, taking risks and
challenging the status quo, empowering others; maximize workforce effectiveness, are
needed to implement planned change that is part of system improvement, determined
by a person's behavior - not job title.
Managers: Guide, direct, and motivate, intervene when goals are threatened, emphasize
control, assigned a position within an organization, have a legitimate source of power
due to the delegated authority that accompanies their position, and are expected to
carry out specific functions.
Together: Leadership and management have a symbiotic relationship and both are
needed for organizational success.
The Management Process
Planning → Organizing → Staffing → Directing → Controlling (repeat)
Planning
Includes determining the philosophy, goals, objectives, policies, procedures, and rules;
performing long- and short-range projections; determining a fiscal course of action; and
implementing planned change
Organizing
-Involves determining the structure through which plans will be carried out, determining
the most effective type of patient care delivery, and organizing activities to meet unit
goals
-Other responsibilities include functioning within the structure of the agency and being
in a position to comprehend and use power and authority effectively
Staffing
,Includes recruitment, interviewing, hiring, and orientation of staff. Often included as
staffing functions are: scheduling, staff development, employee socialization, and team
building
Controlling
Includes: performance appraisals, fiscal accountability, quality control, legal and ethical
control, and professional and collegial control
Management theory: Taylor - Scientific Management
-1900-1930
-increase labor productivity
-minimum standards = minimum work
-workers fit into the organization
Management theory: Weber - Bureaucratic functions
-formal authority-the top makes the decisions
-rules, regulations, structure
-lack the relationship element
Management theory: Fayol and Gulick- Management Organizations
-Planning, Directing, and Staffing
-"the circle"
Management theory: Follett - Participative management
-part of the "Human Relations Era" from 1930-1970
-focuses on human beings and relationships
-Managers should have authority with, not over
, Management theory: Mayo - Hawthorne effect
-People will modify their behavior if they are being observed-improve work
Management theory: McGregor - Theory X and Y
Theory X: authoritarian style. Hands on/micromanage. Assumes workers do not want to
work (Mistrust)
Theory Y: People like their work and will do a good job. Hands-off
The Evolution of Leadership Theory
Industrial: 1900-1930
Human Relations: 1930-1970
1970-Present
-Great man theory/trait theory
-Behavioral/situational/contingency leadership authorities: authoritarian, democratic,
Laissez-faire
-Transaction and transformational
-Full Range leadership theories
Great Man Trait Theories
-Some individuals are normally skilled leaders
-"leaders are born not made"
-People are born either to lead or born to follow
Contingency Leadership Styles
According to contingency leadership, no one style of leadership is fitting for every
situation