SOLUTION MANUAL FOR #z #z
The Legal Environment of Business, 14th Edition by Roger E. Meiners
#z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z
Chapter #z1-22
Chapter #z1
Table of Contents
#z #z
Answer #zto #zDiscussion #zQuestion ............................................................................................... 1
Answers #zto #zCase #zQuestions .................................................................................................... 1
Answers #zto #zEthics #zand #zSocial #zQuestions ............................................................................... 3
Answer to Discussion Question
#z #z #z
Should the common law maxim “Ignorance of the law is no excuse” apply to an immigrant who speaks
little English and was not educated in the United States? How about for a tourist who does not speak
English? Everyone knows criminal acts are prohibited, but what about subtler rules that differ across
countries and so may be misunderstood by foreigners?
Answer: It is generally true that ignorance of the law is no excuse. Citizens are deemed to have
constructive knowledge of the law. Yet, as well known as this rule is, it is surprising how often it is
proffered as an excuse. (A Westlaw search cases finds hundreds of examples). Examples include:
Deluco v. Dezi (Conn. Super) (lack of knowledge regarding the state‘s usury laws is no excuse for
the inclusion of an illegal interest rate in a sales contract); and Plumlee v. Paddock (ignorance of the
fact that the subject matter of the contract was illegal was not excuse). The courts have provided a
small exception to the rule when it comes to people in lack of English language skills. Consider
Flanery v. Kuska, (defendant did not speak English was advised by a friend that an answer to a
complaint was not required); Ramon v. Dept. of Transportation, (no English and an inability to
understand the law required for an excuse); Yurechko v. County of Allegheny, (Ignorance and with
the fact that the municipality suffered no hardship in late lawsuit filing was an excuse).
Answers to Case Questions
1. Facts from an English judge’s decision in 1884: “The crew of an English yacht ......... were cast away in
a storm on the high seas . . . and were compelled to put into an open boat. .......They had no supply
of water and no supply of food. . . . That on the eighteenth day . . . they ....... suggested that one
should be sacrificed to save the rest. . . . That next day . . . they . . . went to the boy ........ put a knife
into his throat and killed him . . . the three men fed upon the body ....... of the boy for four days; [then]
the boat was picked up by a passing vessel, and [they] were rescued. . . . and committed for trial. . . .
if the men had not fed upon the body of the boy they would probably not have survived to be so
picked up and rescued, but would ...... have died of famine. The boy, being in a much weaker
condition, was likely to have died before them ........The real question in this case [is] whether killing
under the conditions set forth ....... be or be not murder.” Do you consider the acts to be immoral?
[Regina v. Dudley and Stephens, 14 Queens Bench Division 273 (1884)]
Answer: This points out that the legal system has limits. Its acceptability is dictated by legal culture--which
determines whether law will be enforced, obeyed, avoided, or abused. It is limited by the informal
rules of the society--its customs and values. One limit is the extent to which society will allow the
formal rules to be imposed when a crime is committed in odd circumstances. Here there was an
intentional murder. Does the motive for the murder, the effort to save several lives by sacrificing one
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 1
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
, life, #zmake #zit #za #zcrime #zthat #zshould #zbe #zpunished? #zNot #zall #zcrimes #zare #ztreated #zthe #zsame. #zIt
#zalso #zraises #zquestions #zabout #zthe #zdesirability #zof #znot #zgiving #zjudges #zflexibility #zin #zsentencing.
There #zwas #za #zprecedent #zfor #za #zlight #zsentence #zin #zthis #zcase #zin #zU.S. #zlaw: #zU.S. #zv. #zHolmes,
#z20 #zF. #zCas. #z360 #z(No. #z15383) #z(C.C.E.D. #zPa. #z1842). #zThe #zcase #zinvolved #za #zsinking #zocean
#zliner. #zSeveral #zpassengers #zmade #zit #zto #zthe #zonly #zlifeboat, #zwhich #zwas #zfar #ztoo #zovercrowded.
#zThe #zcaptain #zdecided #zto #zsave #zthe #zwomen #zand #zchildren #zand #zthrew #zseveral #zmen #zoverboard.
#zThe #zlifeboat #zwas #zrescued. #zThe #zgrand #zjury #zrefused #zto # z indict #zthe #zcaptain #zfrom #zmurder,
#zonly #zfor #zmanslaughter. #zHe #zgot #za #zsix #zmonth #zsentence.
The #zBritish #zjudge #zin #zthe #zcase #zhere #zimposed #zthe #zdeath #zpenalty #zupon #zthe #zperson #zwho
#zsurvived. #zThe #zjudge #zfound #zit #zdifficult #zto #zrule #zthat #zevery #zman #zon #zboard #zhad #zthe #zright
#zto #zmake #zlaw #zby #zhis #zown #zhand. #zThe #zCrown #zreduced #zthe #zsentence #zto #zsix #zmonths.
2. Smoking #zis #za #zserious #zhealth #zhazard. #zCigarettes #zare #zlegal. #zShould #zcigarette #zmanufacturers
#zbe #zliable #zfor #zthe #zserious #zillnesses #zand #zuntimely #zdeaths #zcaused #zby #ztheir #zunavoidably
#zdangerous #zproducts, #zeven #zthough #zthey #zpost #za #zwarning #zon #zthe #zpackage #zand #zconsumers
#zvoluntarily #zassume #zthe #zhealth #zrisks #zby #zsmoking? #z[Cipollone #zv. #zLiggett #zGroup, #zInc., #z505
#zU.S. #z504 #z(1992)]
Answer: #zThe #zgeneral #zrule #zthat #zexists #znow #zis #zthat #zsince #zthe #zgovernment #zhas #zordered #zthe
#zposting #zof #zwarning #zlabels #zon #zcigarettes, #zand #zsince #zthe #zdangers #zof #zsmoking #zare #zwell
#zknown, #zconsumers #zhave #zbeen #zwarned #zand #zare #znot #zdue #zcompensation #zif #zthey #zkill
#zthemselves #zby #zsmoking. #zThe #zCippoline #zcase, #zsince #zreviewed #zby #zthe #zSupreme #zCourt,
#zappears #zto #zbe #zof #zlimited #zimpact #zsince #zthe #zvictim #zwas #zadjudged #zto #zhave #zbecome
#zaddicted #zto #zcigarettes #zbefore #zthe #zwarning #zlabel #zwas #zordered #zin #z1964. #zIf #zcigarette #zmakers
#zwere #zheld #zresponsible #zfor #zall #zhealth #zproblems #zassociated #zwith #zcigarettes, #zthen, #zlike
#zalcohol #zand #zother #zdangerous #zproducts, #zthe #zdamages #zwould #zlikely #zbe #zso #zhigh #zit #zwould
#zeffectively #zban #zthe #zproducts. #zPresumably, #zin #za #zfree #zsociety #zif #zadults #zare #zclearly #zinformed
#zof #zthe #zrisks #zof #zproducts #zthat #zcannot #zbe #zmade #zsafe, #zthey #zaccept #zthe #zrisk. #zTobacco #zand
#zalcohol #zproducers #zcannot #ztake #zthe #zdangers #zout #zof #zthe #zproducts #zexcept #zat #zthe #zmargin #zby
#zencouraging #zresponsible #zdrinking #zand #zthe #zlike. #zAre #zdrugs #zlike #zcocaine #zdifferent?
3. Two #zeight-year-old #zboys #zwere #zseriously #zinjured #zwhen #zriding #zHonda #zmini-trail #zbikes. #zThe
#zboys #zwere #zriding #zon #zpublic #zstreets, #zran #za #zstop #zsign, #zand #zwere #zhit #zby #za #ztruck. #zThe
#zbikes #zhad #zclear #zwarning #zlabels #zon #zthe #zfront #zstating #zthey #zwere #zonly #zfor #zoff-road #zuse. #zThe
#zmanual #zstated #zthe #zbikes #zwere #znot #zto #zbe #zused #zon #zpublic #zstreets. #zThe #zparents #zsued
#zHonda. #zThe #zsupreme #zcourt #zof #zWashington #zsaid #zone #zbasic #zissue #zexisted: #z“Is #za
#zmanufacturer #zliable #zwhen #zchildren #zare #zinjured #zwhile #zriding #zone #zof #zits #zmini-trail #zbikes #zon #za
#zpublic #zroad #zin #zviolation #zof #zmanufacturer #zand #zparental #zwarnings?” #zIs #zit #zunethical #zto #zmake
#zproducts #zlike #zmini-trail #zbikes #zchildren #zwill #zuse #zwhen #zwe #zknow #zaccidents #zlike #zthis #zwill
#zhappen? #z[Baughn #zv. #zHonda #zMotor #zCo., #z727 #zP.2d #z655 #zSup. #zCt, #zWash., #z(1986)]
Answer: #zThe #zcourt #zfound #zno #zliability #zfor #zthe #zmanufacturers. #zThere #zwas #zno #zdefect; #zthe #zproduct
#zwas #zsafe #zfor #zintended #zuse. #zSafety #zinstructions #zwere #zclear; #zthe #zparents #zlet #zthe #zboys #zride
#zthe #zbikes. #zAnything #zcan #zbe #zdangerous--baseballs #zare #zdangerous #zwhen #zthey #zhit #zthe #zhead,
#zswings #zare #zdangerous #zwhen #zkids #zjump #zout #zof #zthem; #zthere #zis #zonly #zso #zmuch #zthat #zcan #zbe
#zdone #zto #zmake #zthe #zgovernment #zthe #z―national #znanny‖ #zas #zthe #zWashington #zPost #zonce #zsaid
#zabout #zexcessive #zconsumer #zprotection. #zParents #zmust #zaccept #za #zhigh #zdegree #zof #zresponsible
#zfor #ztheir #zown #zchildren.
4. Johnson #zControls #zadopted #za #z“fetal #zprotection #zpolicy” #zthat #zwomen #zof #zchildbearing #zage
#zcould #znot #zwork #zin #zthe #zbattery-making #zdivision #zof #zthe #zcompany. #zExposure #zto #zlead #zin #zthe
#zbattery #zoperation #zcould #zcause #zharm #zto #zunborn #zbabies. #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zconcerned
#zabout #zpossible #zlegal #zliability #zfor #zinjury #zsuffered #zby #zbabies #zof #zmothers #zwho #zhad #zworked #zin
#zthe #zbattery #zdivision. #zThe #zSupreme #zCourt #zheld #zthe #zcompany #zpolicy #zwas #zillegal. #zIt #zwas #zan
#z“excuse #zfor #zdenying #zwomen #zequal #zemployment #zopportunities.” #zIs #zthe #zCourt #zforcing #zthe
#zcompany #zto #zbe #zunethical #zby #zallowing #zpregnant #zwomen #zwho #zignore #zthe #zwarnings #zto
#zexpose #ztheir #zbabies #zto #zthe #zlead? #z[United #zAuto #zWorkers #zv. #zJohnson #zControls, #z499 #zU.S.
#z187 #z(1991)]
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 2
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
,Answer: #zThe #zCourt #zheld #zit #za #zform #zof #zsex #zdiscrimination #zto #zprevent #zwomen #zof #zchild-bearing
#zage #zfrom #zholding #zthe #zmore #zdangerous #zjobs. #zThe #zcompany #zargued #zthat #zit #zdid #zthis #zto
#zprotect #zitself #zfrom #zpossible #zliability #zin #zcase #zof #zdamage #zto #zbabies #zand #zthat #zthe #zdecision
#zwas #zethical. #zThe #zreplacements #zfor #zthese #zworkers #zwere #zoften #zmen #zor #zmore #zsenior
#zwomen, #zwho #ztended #zto #zbe #zhigher #zincome #zworkers, #zso #zthis
was #znot #za #zcurrent #zcost-saving #zmove. #zNote #zthat #za #z2002 #zruling #zrelated #zto #zthe #zADA
#zsignificantly #zrestricted #zthis #zearlier #zcase.
5. McGrory #zworked #zfor #zApplied #zSignal #zTechnology #zin #za #zsupervisory #zposition. #zHe #zwas
#zaccused #zof #zviolating #zthe #zcompany’s #zpolicies #zon #zsexual #zharassment. #zAn #zinternal
#zinvestigation #zdetermined #zhe #zdid #znot #zviolate #zthe #zpolicy #zbut #zthat #zhe #zwas #zevasive #zand
#zviolated #zthe #zcompany’s #zpersonal #zethics #zcode. #zHe #zwas #zfired #zand #zsued #zfor #zwrongful
#ztermination, #zcontending #zthat #zif #zhe #zdid #znot #zviolate #zsexual #zharassment #zrules #zhe #zshould #znot
#zhave #zbeen #zsubject #zto #ztermination. #zDo #zstandards #zof #zlaw #zand #zethics #zneed #zto #zbe #zthe #zsame
#zfor #zan #zemployer? #z[McGrory #zv. #zApplied #zSignal #zTechnology, #z152 #zCal.Rptr.3d #z154 #z(2013)]
Answer: #zThe #zappeals #zcourt #zaffirmed #zthat #zthe #zemployer #zhad #zthe #zright #zto #zterminate #zthe
#zemployee #zfor #zfailure #zto #zbe #zfully #zcooperative #zin #zthe #zinvestigation #zof #zthe #zcomplaint #zof
#zsexual #zharassment #zthat #zhad #zbeen #zfiled #zagainst #zhim. #zWhile #zhe #zwas #znot #zfound #zto #zhave
#zviolated #zthe #zharassment #zpolicy, #zhe #zwas #zevasive #zand #zuncooperative, #zwhich #zviolated #zthe
#zcompany‘s #zcode #zof #zethics, #zwhich #zwas #za #zjustification #zfor #ztermination.
6. Baker #zworks #zas #za #zdocument #zclerk #zfor #zthe #zMinnesota #zSupreme #zCourt. #zAfter #zshe #zhad
#zworked #zthere #zfor #z13 #zyears #zthe #zMinnesota #zjudicial #zbranch #zadopted #za #zpolicy #zconcerning
#zproper #zInternet #zuse #zand #zstated #zthat #zemployees #zmust #zadhere #zto #zthe #zhighest #zethical
#zstandards #zwhen #zusing #zthe #zInternet. #zEleven #zyears #zlater, #zshe #zwas #zfired #zfor #zexcessive
#zsurfing #zon #zthe #zInternet #zduring #zworking #zhours. #zShe #zcontended #zshe #zdid #znot #zknow #zabout
#zthe #zpolicy. #zIs #zthat #zan #zadequate #zdefense #zfor #zher? #z[Baker #zv. #zMinnesota #zSupreme #zCourt,
#z2016 #zWL #z102513 #z(2016)]
Answer: #zThe #zMinnesota #zhigh #zcourt #zheld #zthat #zBaker‘s #ztermination #zwas #zproper. #zShe #zviolated
#zstandards #zexpected #zof #zemployees. #zShe #zhad #zbeen #zwarned #zabout #zexcessive #zpersonal
#zInternet #zuse #zduring #zwork #ztime, #zincluding #zbuying #zand #zselling #zgoods #zfor #za #zlittle #zbusiness
#zshe #zran. #zThe #zclaim #zthat #zshe #zdid #znot #zknow #zabout #zthe #zethics #zof #zInternet #zuse #zwas #znot
#zcredible #zas #zthe #zpolicy #zwas #zposted #zfor #zall #zemployees #zwho #zreceived #ze-mails #zabout #zany
#zchanges #zto #zthe #zpolicy. #zThe #zfact #zthat #zthe #zterm #z―ethical‖ #zwas #zused #zin #zthe #zpolicy #zdoes #znot
#zlikely #zimpact #zthis #zdecision.
Answers to Ethics and Social Questions
#z #z #z #z #z
1. The #zfederal #ztax #zcode #zis #zriddled #zwith #zspecial-interest #zloopholes. #zMost #zof #zthese #zexist
#zbecause #zfirms #zand #ztrade #zassociations #zlobby #zCongress #zand #zprovide #zcampaign #zsupport #zto
#zmembers #zof #zCongress #zto #zgain #zspecial #zfavors #zto #zindividual #zfirms #zor #zindustries. #zIs #zit
#zethical #zfor #zfirms #zto #zseek #zspecial #zprivilege?
Answer: #zThe #znature #zof #zour #zpolitical #zsystem #zforces #zfirms #zto #zparticipate #zin #zthe #zpolitical #zprocess.
#zThose #zthat #zfail #zto #zdo #zso, #zif #zthey #zare #zof #zany #zsize, #zare #zmore #zlikely #zto #zbe #zsubject #zto
#zpolitical #zattack. #zIn #za #zsense, #zfirms
―buy‖ #zprotection #zby #zkeeping #za #zflow #zof #zcontributions #zgoing, #zespecially #zto #zincumbent
#zmembers #zof #zCongress. #zCompetition #zalso #zmeans #zthat #zif #za #zfirm #zdoes #znot #zlobby #zfor #zspecial
#zprivilege, #zthen #zit #zmay #zsuffer #zif #zcompetitors #zachieve #zsuch #zstatus #zin #zthe #ztax #zcode #zor #zsome
#zarea #zof #zregulation. #zMany #zbusiness #zleaders #zdo #znot #zmuch #zcare #zfor #zthe #zWashington, #zD.C.
#zoperations #ztheir #zfirms #zsupport #zbut #zknow #zthat #zit #zis #za #zpart #zof #zthe #zmodern #zlegal
#zenvironment #zof #zbusiness.
2. “Fair #ztrade” #zgoods #zhave #zbecome #zpopular, #zas #zsome #zpeople #zare #zwilling #zto #zpay #zmore #zto
#zknow #zthe #zgoods #zcome #zfrom #zworkers #zpaid #za #zdecent #zprice #zfor #ztheir #zefforts. #zHowever,
#zsome #zretailers #zwho #zsell #zfair #ztrade #zgoods #zmark #zthem #zup #zsubstantially #zmore #zthan #znonfair
#ztrade #zgoods. #zOne #zstudy #zshowed #zthat #zcoffee #zgrowers #zgot #zan #zaverage #zof #z44 #zcents #za
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 3
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
, #zpound #zmore #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zcoffee, #zbut #zthe #zcoffee #zat #zretail #zwas #zmarked #zup #zan #zadditional
#z$3.46 #zper #zpound. #zAt #zone #zsupermarket #zchain, #zfair #ztrade #zbananas #zthat #zcost #zan #zextra #z3.6
#zcents #zper #zpound #zwere #zmarked #zup #zfour #ztimes #zthe #zprice #zof #znon-fair #ztrade #zbananas. #zFair
#ztrade #zgoods #zare #zclaimed #zto #zbe #za #zform #zof #zsocial #zresponsibility. #zIs #zthat #ztrue #zif #zit #zjust
#zmeans #zhigher #zprofit #zmargins?
3. Answer: #zThe #zhigh #zmark #zup #zsuppresses #zthe #zdemand #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zgoods, #zthereby
#zreducing #zthe #zmarket #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zgoods. #zIf #zthe #zretail #zprices #zreflected #zthe #zactual
#zadditional #zcost, #znot #zthe #zprofit #zmaximizing #zprice #zto #zthe #zretailer #zthat #zexploits #zthe
#zgoodwill #zfrom #z―fair #ztrade,‖ #zthen #zit #zis #zhard #zto #zargue #zthat #zthe #zcompany #zis #zbeing
#zparticularly #zsocially #zresponsibleA #zchemical #zcompany #zlocated #za #znew #zplant #zin #za
#zdepressed #zarea #zwith #zhigh #zunemployment #zin #zWest #zVirginia. #zIt #zbuilt #za #zstate-of-the-art #zplant
#zthat #zhad #zthe #zlatest #zpollution #zcontrol #ztechnology #zmeeting #zall #zEPA #zrequirements. #zIt #zcreated
#z2,500 #zjobs. #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zattacked #zfor #zpolluting #za #zpreviously #zpristine #zarea. #zHad #zthe
#zplant #zbeen #zbuilt #zin #zan #zindustrial #zarea, #zsuch #zas #zthe #zcoast #znear #zHouston, #zno #zone #zwould
#zhave #zbeen #zlikely #zto #zcomplain. #zWas #zthe #zcompany #zsocially #zirresponsible #zfor #zbuilding #zthe
#zplant #zin #zsuch #zan #zarea?
Answer: #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zin #za #zno-win #zsituation. #zIt #zwas #zattacked #zby #zenvironmentalists #zand #zsome
#zlocals #zfor
―destroying‖ #zthe #zenvironment, #zeven #zthough #zthe #zpollution #zwas #zacceptable. #zWhen #zthe
#zcompany #zlater #zstated #zit #zwould #zclose #zthe #zplant, #zwhich #zas #znot #zprofitable, #zit #zcame #zunder
#zfire #zfor #zdestroying #zjobs. #zIt #zeventually #zupgraded #zthe #zplant #zand #zkept #zit #zopen, #zbut #zit #zwas
#znever #za #zprofitable #zoperation. #zThe #zplant #zshould #zprobably #znot #zhave #zbeen #zbuilt #zin #zsuch
#za #zremote #zlocation, #zas #zthat #zmade #zit #za #ztarget. #zBuilt #zin #za #zhigher-density #zarea #zand #zthere
#zwould #zhave #zbeen #zfewer #zissues #zas #zthe #zenvironmental #zimpact #zon #zan #zexisting #zindustrial
#zarea #zwould #zhave #zbeen #zsmall. #zCorporate #zsocial #zresponsibility #zcan #zinvolve #zdifficult
#ztradeoffs #zthat #zdo #znot #zalways #zallow #za #zwin-win #zresult.
4. Discussion #zof #zethics #zissues #zfocuses #zon #zcompany #zexamples. #zWhat #zpersonal #zethics #zmatter?
#zSurveys #zindicate #zthat #zmany #zstudents #zhave #zcheated #zin #zclasses #zone #zway #zor #zanother,
#zpad #ztheir #zresumes #zwhen #zseeking #zjobs, #zand #zhave #zimproperly #zdownloaded #zcopyrighted
#zmusic. #zDoes #zethics #z“begin #zat #zhome”?
Answer: #zIf #zethics #zis #zto #zbe #ztheoretical #zor #zapplied #zonly #zin #zformal #zsituations, #zthen #zit #zmeans #zlittle #zin
#zpractice.
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 4
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
The Legal Environment of Business, 14th Edition by Roger E. Meiners
#z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z #z
Chapter #z1-22
Chapter #z1
Table of Contents
#z #z
Answer #zto #zDiscussion #zQuestion ............................................................................................... 1
Answers #zto #zCase #zQuestions .................................................................................................... 1
Answers #zto #zEthics #zand #zSocial #zQuestions ............................................................................... 3
Answer to Discussion Question
#z #z #z
Should the common law maxim “Ignorance of the law is no excuse” apply to an immigrant who speaks
little English and was not educated in the United States? How about for a tourist who does not speak
English? Everyone knows criminal acts are prohibited, but what about subtler rules that differ across
countries and so may be misunderstood by foreigners?
Answer: It is generally true that ignorance of the law is no excuse. Citizens are deemed to have
constructive knowledge of the law. Yet, as well known as this rule is, it is surprising how often it is
proffered as an excuse. (A Westlaw search cases finds hundreds of examples). Examples include:
Deluco v. Dezi (Conn. Super) (lack of knowledge regarding the state‘s usury laws is no excuse for
the inclusion of an illegal interest rate in a sales contract); and Plumlee v. Paddock (ignorance of the
fact that the subject matter of the contract was illegal was not excuse). The courts have provided a
small exception to the rule when it comes to people in lack of English language skills. Consider
Flanery v. Kuska, (defendant did not speak English was advised by a friend that an answer to a
complaint was not required); Ramon v. Dept. of Transportation, (no English and an inability to
understand the law required for an excuse); Yurechko v. County of Allegheny, (Ignorance and with
the fact that the municipality suffered no hardship in late lawsuit filing was an excuse).
Answers to Case Questions
1. Facts from an English judge’s decision in 1884: “The crew of an English yacht ......... were cast away in
a storm on the high seas . . . and were compelled to put into an open boat. .......They had no supply
of water and no supply of food. . . . That on the eighteenth day . . . they ....... suggested that one
should be sacrificed to save the rest. . . . That next day . . . they . . . went to the boy ........ put a knife
into his throat and killed him . . . the three men fed upon the body ....... of the boy for four days; [then]
the boat was picked up by a passing vessel, and [they] were rescued. . . . and committed for trial. . . .
if the men had not fed upon the body of the boy they would probably not have survived to be so
picked up and rescued, but would ...... have died of famine. The boy, being in a much weaker
condition, was likely to have died before them ........The real question in this case [is] whether killing
under the conditions set forth ....... be or be not murder.” Do you consider the acts to be immoral?
[Regina v. Dudley and Stephens, 14 Queens Bench Division 273 (1884)]
Answer: This points out that the legal system has limits. Its acceptability is dictated by legal culture--which
determines whether law will be enforced, obeyed, avoided, or abused. It is limited by the informal
rules of the society--its customs and values. One limit is the extent to which society will allow the
formal rules to be imposed when a crime is committed in odd circumstances. Here there was an
intentional murder. Does the motive for the murder, the effort to save several lives by sacrificing one
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 1
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
, life, #zmake #zit #za #zcrime #zthat #zshould #zbe #zpunished? #zNot #zall #zcrimes #zare #ztreated #zthe #zsame. #zIt
#zalso #zraises #zquestions #zabout #zthe #zdesirability #zof #znot #zgiving #zjudges #zflexibility #zin #zsentencing.
There #zwas #za #zprecedent #zfor #za #zlight #zsentence #zin #zthis #zcase #zin #zU.S. #zlaw: #zU.S. #zv. #zHolmes,
#z20 #zF. #zCas. #z360 #z(No. #z15383) #z(C.C.E.D. #zPa. #z1842). #zThe #zcase #zinvolved #za #zsinking #zocean
#zliner. #zSeveral #zpassengers #zmade #zit #zto #zthe #zonly #zlifeboat, #zwhich #zwas #zfar #ztoo #zovercrowded.
#zThe #zcaptain #zdecided #zto #zsave #zthe #zwomen #zand #zchildren #zand #zthrew #zseveral #zmen #zoverboard.
#zThe #zlifeboat #zwas #zrescued. #zThe #zgrand #zjury #zrefused #zto # z indict #zthe #zcaptain #zfrom #zmurder,
#zonly #zfor #zmanslaughter. #zHe #zgot #za #zsix #zmonth #zsentence.
The #zBritish #zjudge #zin #zthe #zcase #zhere #zimposed #zthe #zdeath #zpenalty #zupon #zthe #zperson #zwho
#zsurvived. #zThe #zjudge #zfound #zit #zdifficult #zto #zrule #zthat #zevery #zman #zon #zboard #zhad #zthe #zright
#zto #zmake #zlaw #zby #zhis #zown #zhand. #zThe #zCrown #zreduced #zthe #zsentence #zto #zsix #zmonths.
2. Smoking #zis #za #zserious #zhealth #zhazard. #zCigarettes #zare #zlegal. #zShould #zcigarette #zmanufacturers
#zbe #zliable #zfor #zthe #zserious #zillnesses #zand #zuntimely #zdeaths #zcaused #zby #ztheir #zunavoidably
#zdangerous #zproducts, #zeven #zthough #zthey #zpost #za #zwarning #zon #zthe #zpackage #zand #zconsumers
#zvoluntarily #zassume #zthe #zhealth #zrisks #zby #zsmoking? #z[Cipollone #zv. #zLiggett #zGroup, #zInc., #z505
#zU.S. #z504 #z(1992)]
Answer: #zThe #zgeneral #zrule #zthat #zexists #znow #zis #zthat #zsince #zthe #zgovernment #zhas #zordered #zthe
#zposting #zof #zwarning #zlabels #zon #zcigarettes, #zand #zsince #zthe #zdangers #zof #zsmoking #zare #zwell
#zknown, #zconsumers #zhave #zbeen #zwarned #zand #zare #znot #zdue #zcompensation #zif #zthey #zkill
#zthemselves #zby #zsmoking. #zThe #zCippoline #zcase, #zsince #zreviewed #zby #zthe #zSupreme #zCourt,
#zappears #zto #zbe #zof #zlimited #zimpact #zsince #zthe #zvictim #zwas #zadjudged #zto #zhave #zbecome
#zaddicted #zto #zcigarettes #zbefore #zthe #zwarning #zlabel #zwas #zordered #zin #z1964. #zIf #zcigarette #zmakers
#zwere #zheld #zresponsible #zfor #zall #zhealth #zproblems #zassociated #zwith #zcigarettes, #zthen, #zlike
#zalcohol #zand #zother #zdangerous #zproducts, #zthe #zdamages #zwould #zlikely #zbe #zso #zhigh #zit #zwould
#zeffectively #zban #zthe #zproducts. #zPresumably, #zin #za #zfree #zsociety #zif #zadults #zare #zclearly #zinformed
#zof #zthe #zrisks #zof #zproducts #zthat #zcannot #zbe #zmade #zsafe, #zthey #zaccept #zthe #zrisk. #zTobacco #zand
#zalcohol #zproducers #zcannot #ztake #zthe #zdangers #zout #zof #zthe #zproducts #zexcept #zat #zthe #zmargin #zby
#zencouraging #zresponsible #zdrinking #zand #zthe #zlike. #zAre #zdrugs #zlike #zcocaine #zdifferent?
3. Two #zeight-year-old #zboys #zwere #zseriously #zinjured #zwhen #zriding #zHonda #zmini-trail #zbikes. #zThe
#zboys #zwere #zriding #zon #zpublic #zstreets, #zran #za #zstop #zsign, #zand #zwere #zhit #zby #za #ztruck. #zThe
#zbikes #zhad #zclear #zwarning #zlabels #zon #zthe #zfront #zstating #zthey #zwere #zonly #zfor #zoff-road #zuse. #zThe
#zmanual #zstated #zthe #zbikes #zwere #znot #zto #zbe #zused #zon #zpublic #zstreets. #zThe #zparents #zsued
#zHonda. #zThe #zsupreme #zcourt #zof #zWashington #zsaid #zone #zbasic #zissue #zexisted: #z“Is #za
#zmanufacturer #zliable #zwhen #zchildren #zare #zinjured #zwhile #zriding #zone #zof #zits #zmini-trail #zbikes #zon #za
#zpublic #zroad #zin #zviolation #zof #zmanufacturer #zand #zparental #zwarnings?” #zIs #zit #zunethical #zto #zmake
#zproducts #zlike #zmini-trail #zbikes #zchildren #zwill #zuse #zwhen #zwe #zknow #zaccidents #zlike #zthis #zwill
#zhappen? #z[Baughn #zv. #zHonda #zMotor #zCo., #z727 #zP.2d #z655 #zSup. #zCt, #zWash., #z(1986)]
Answer: #zThe #zcourt #zfound #zno #zliability #zfor #zthe #zmanufacturers. #zThere #zwas #zno #zdefect; #zthe #zproduct
#zwas #zsafe #zfor #zintended #zuse. #zSafety #zinstructions #zwere #zclear; #zthe #zparents #zlet #zthe #zboys #zride
#zthe #zbikes. #zAnything #zcan #zbe #zdangerous--baseballs #zare #zdangerous #zwhen #zthey #zhit #zthe #zhead,
#zswings #zare #zdangerous #zwhen #zkids #zjump #zout #zof #zthem; #zthere #zis #zonly #zso #zmuch #zthat #zcan #zbe
#zdone #zto #zmake #zthe #zgovernment #zthe #z―national #znanny‖ #zas #zthe #zWashington #zPost #zonce #zsaid
#zabout #zexcessive #zconsumer #zprotection. #zParents #zmust #zaccept #za #zhigh #zdegree #zof #zresponsible
#zfor #ztheir #zown #zchildren.
4. Johnson #zControls #zadopted #za #z“fetal #zprotection #zpolicy” #zthat #zwomen #zof #zchildbearing #zage
#zcould #znot #zwork #zin #zthe #zbattery-making #zdivision #zof #zthe #zcompany. #zExposure #zto #zlead #zin #zthe
#zbattery #zoperation #zcould #zcause #zharm #zto #zunborn #zbabies. #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zconcerned
#zabout #zpossible #zlegal #zliability #zfor #zinjury #zsuffered #zby #zbabies #zof #zmothers #zwho #zhad #zworked #zin
#zthe #zbattery #zdivision. #zThe #zSupreme #zCourt #zheld #zthe #zcompany #zpolicy #zwas #zillegal. #zIt #zwas #zan
#z“excuse #zfor #zdenying #zwomen #zequal #zemployment #zopportunities.” #zIs #zthe #zCourt #zforcing #zthe
#zcompany #zto #zbe #zunethical #zby #zallowing #zpregnant #zwomen #zwho #zignore #zthe #zwarnings #zto
#zexpose #ztheir #zbabies #zto #zthe #zlead? #z[United #zAuto #zWorkers #zv. #zJohnson #zControls, #z499 #zU.S.
#z187 #z(1991)]
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 2
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
,Answer: #zThe #zCourt #zheld #zit #za #zform #zof #zsex #zdiscrimination #zto #zprevent #zwomen #zof #zchild-bearing
#zage #zfrom #zholding #zthe #zmore #zdangerous #zjobs. #zThe #zcompany #zargued #zthat #zit #zdid #zthis #zto
#zprotect #zitself #zfrom #zpossible #zliability #zin #zcase #zof #zdamage #zto #zbabies #zand #zthat #zthe #zdecision
#zwas #zethical. #zThe #zreplacements #zfor #zthese #zworkers #zwere #zoften #zmen #zor #zmore #zsenior
#zwomen, #zwho #ztended #zto #zbe #zhigher #zincome #zworkers, #zso #zthis
was #znot #za #zcurrent #zcost-saving #zmove. #zNote #zthat #za #z2002 #zruling #zrelated #zto #zthe #zADA
#zsignificantly #zrestricted #zthis #zearlier #zcase.
5. McGrory #zworked #zfor #zApplied #zSignal #zTechnology #zin #za #zsupervisory #zposition. #zHe #zwas
#zaccused #zof #zviolating #zthe #zcompany’s #zpolicies #zon #zsexual #zharassment. #zAn #zinternal
#zinvestigation #zdetermined #zhe #zdid #znot #zviolate #zthe #zpolicy #zbut #zthat #zhe #zwas #zevasive #zand
#zviolated #zthe #zcompany’s #zpersonal #zethics #zcode. #zHe #zwas #zfired #zand #zsued #zfor #zwrongful
#ztermination, #zcontending #zthat #zif #zhe #zdid #znot #zviolate #zsexual #zharassment #zrules #zhe #zshould #znot
#zhave #zbeen #zsubject #zto #ztermination. #zDo #zstandards #zof #zlaw #zand #zethics #zneed #zto #zbe #zthe #zsame
#zfor #zan #zemployer? #z[McGrory #zv. #zApplied #zSignal #zTechnology, #z152 #zCal.Rptr.3d #z154 #z(2013)]
Answer: #zThe #zappeals #zcourt #zaffirmed #zthat #zthe #zemployer #zhad #zthe #zright #zto #zterminate #zthe
#zemployee #zfor #zfailure #zto #zbe #zfully #zcooperative #zin #zthe #zinvestigation #zof #zthe #zcomplaint #zof
#zsexual #zharassment #zthat #zhad #zbeen #zfiled #zagainst #zhim. #zWhile #zhe #zwas #znot #zfound #zto #zhave
#zviolated #zthe #zharassment #zpolicy, #zhe #zwas #zevasive #zand #zuncooperative, #zwhich #zviolated #zthe
#zcompany‘s #zcode #zof #zethics, #zwhich #zwas #za #zjustification #zfor #ztermination.
6. Baker #zworks #zas #za #zdocument #zclerk #zfor #zthe #zMinnesota #zSupreme #zCourt. #zAfter #zshe #zhad
#zworked #zthere #zfor #z13 #zyears #zthe #zMinnesota #zjudicial #zbranch #zadopted #za #zpolicy #zconcerning
#zproper #zInternet #zuse #zand #zstated #zthat #zemployees #zmust #zadhere #zto #zthe #zhighest #zethical
#zstandards #zwhen #zusing #zthe #zInternet. #zEleven #zyears #zlater, #zshe #zwas #zfired #zfor #zexcessive
#zsurfing #zon #zthe #zInternet #zduring #zworking #zhours. #zShe #zcontended #zshe #zdid #znot #zknow #zabout
#zthe #zpolicy. #zIs #zthat #zan #zadequate #zdefense #zfor #zher? #z[Baker #zv. #zMinnesota #zSupreme #zCourt,
#z2016 #zWL #z102513 #z(2016)]
Answer: #zThe #zMinnesota #zhigh #zcourt #zheld #zthat #zBaker‘s #ztermination #zwas #zproper. #zShe #zviolated
#zstandards #zexpected #zof #zemployees. #zShe #zhad #zbeen #zwarned #zabout #zexcessive #zpersonal
#zInternet #zuse #zduring #zwork #ztime, #zincluding #zbuying #zand #zselling #zgoods #zfor #za #zlittle #zbusiness
#zshe #zran. #zThe #zclaim #zthat #zshe #zdid #znot #zknow #zabout #zthe #zethics #zof #zInternet #zuse #zwas #znot
#zcredible #zas #zthe #zpolicy #zwas #zposted #zfor #zall #zemployees #zwho #zreceived #ze-mails #zabout #zany
#zchanges #zto #zthe #zpolicy. #zThe #zfact #zthat #zthe #zterm #z―ethical‖ #zwas #zused #zin #zthe #zpolicy #zdoes #znot
#zlikely #zimpact #zthis #zdecision.
Answers to Ethics and Social Questions
#z #z #z #z #z
1. The #zfederal #ztax #zcode #zis #zriddled #zwith #zspecial-interest #zloopholes. #zMost #zof #zthese #zexist
#zbecause #zfirms #zand #ztrade #zassociations #zlobby #zCongress #zand #zprovide #zcampaign #zsupport #zto
#zmembers #zof #zCongress #zto #zgain #zspecial #zfavors #zto #zindividual #zfirms #zor #zindustries. #zIs #zit
#zethical #zfor #zfirms #zto #zseek #zspecial #zprivilege?
Answer: #zThe #znature #zof #zour #zpolitical #zsystem #zforces #zfirms #zto #zparticipate #zin #zthe #zpolitical #zprocess.
#zThose #zthat #zfail #zto #zdo #zso, #zif #zthey #zare #zof #zany #zsize, #zare #zmore #zlikely #zto #zbe #zsubject #zto
#zpolitical #zattack. #zIn #za #zsense, #zfirms
―buy‖ #zprotection #zby #zkeeping #za #zflow #zof #zcontributions #zgoing, #zespecially #zto #zincumbent
#zmembers #zof #zCongress. #zCompetition #zalso #zmeans #zthat #zif #za #zfirm #zdoes #znot #zlobby #zfor #zspecial
#zprivilege, #zthen #zit #zmay #zsuffer #zif #zcompetitors #zachieve #zsuch #zstatus #zin #zthe #ztax #zcode #zor #zsome
#zarea #zof #zregulation. #zMany #zbusiness #zleaders #zdo #znot #zmuch #zcare #zfor #zthe #zWashington, #zD.C.
#zoperations #ztheir #zfirms #zsupport #zbut #zknow #zthat #zit #zis #za #zpart #zof #zthe #zmodern #zlegal
#zenvironment #zof #zbusiness.
2. “Fair #ztrade” #zgoods #zhave #zbecome #zpopular, #zas #zsome #zpeople #zare #zwilling #zto #zpay #zmore #zto
#zknow #zthe #zgoods #zcome #zfrom #zworkers #zpaid #za #zdecent #zprice #zfor #ztheir #zefforts. #zHowever,
#zsome #zretailers #zwho #zsell #zfair #ztrade #zgoods #zmark #zthem #zup #zsubstantially #zmore #zthan #znonfair
#ztrade #zgoods. #zOne #zstudy #zshowed #zthat #zcoffee #zgrowers #zgot #zan #zaverage #zof #z44 #zcents #za
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 3
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
, #zpound #zmore #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zcoffee, #zbut #zthe #zcoffee #zat #zretail #zwas #zmarked #zup #zan #zadditional
#z$3.46 #zper #zpound. #zAt #zone #zsupermarket #zchain, #zfair #ztrade #zbananas #zthat #zcost #zan #zextra #z3.6
#zcents #zper #zpound #zwere #zmarked #zup #zfour #ztimes #zthe #zprice #zof #znon-fair #ztrade #zbananas. #zFair
#ztrade #zgoods #zare #zclaimed #zto #zbe #za #zform #zof #zsocial #zresponsibility. #zIs #zthat #ztrue #zif #zit #zjust
#zmeans #zhigher #zprofit #zmargins?
3. Answer: #zThe #zhigh #zmark #zup #zsuppresses #zthe #zdemand #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zgoods, #zthereby
#zreducing #zthe #zmarket #zfor #zfair #ztrade #zgoods. #zIf #zthe #zretail #zprices #zreflected #zthe #zactual
#zadditional #zcost, #znot #zthe #zprofit #zmaximizing #zprice #zto #zthe #zretailer #zthat #zexploits #zthe
#zgoodwill #zfrom #z―fair #ztrade,‖ #zthen #zit #zis #zhard #zto #zargue #zthat #zthe #zcompany #zis #zbeing
#zparticularly #zsocially #zresponsibleA #zchemical #zcompany #zlocated #za #znew #zplant #zin #za
#zdepressed #zarea #zwith #zhigh #zunemployment #zin #zWest #zVirginia. #zIt #zbuilt #za #zstate-of-the-art #zplant
#zthat #zhad #zthe #zlatest #zpollution #zcontrol #ztechnology #zmeeting #zall #zEPA #zrequirements. #zIt #zcreated
#z2,500 #zjobs. #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zattacked #zfor #zpolluting #za #zpreviously #zpristine #zarea. #zHad #zthe
#zplant #zbeen #zbuilt #zin #zan #zindustrial #zarea, #zsuch #zas #zthe #zcoast #znear #zHouston, #zno #zone #zwould
#zhave #zbeen #zlikely #zto #zcomplain. #zWas #zthe #zcompany #zsocially #zirresponsible #zfor #zbuilding #zthe
#zplant #zin #zsuch #zan #zarea?
Answer: #zThe #zcompany #zwas #zin #za #zno-win #zsituation. #zIt #zwas #zattacked #zby #zenvironmentalists #zand #zsome
#zlocals #zfor
―destroying‖ #zthe #zenvironment, #zeven #zthough #zthe #zpollution #zwas #zacceptable. #zWhen #zthe
#zcompany #zlater #zstated #zit #zwould #zclose #zthe #zplant, #zwhich #zas #znot #zprofitable, #zit #zcame #zunder
#zfire #zfor #zdestroying #zjobs. #zIt #zeventually #zupgraded #zthe #zplant #zand #zkept #zit #zopen, #zbut #zit #zwas
#znever #za #zprofitable #zoperation. #zThe #zplant #zshould #zprobably #znot #zhave #zbeen #zbuilt #zin #zsuch
#za #zremote #zlocation, #zas #zthat #zmade #zit #za #ztarget. #zBuilt #zin #za #zhigher-density #zarea #zand #zthere
#zwould #zhave #zbeen #zfewer #zissues #zas #zthe #zenvironmental #zimpact #zon #zan #zexisting #zindustrial
#zarea #zwould #zhave #zbeen #zsmall. #zCorporate #zsocial #zresponsibility #zcan #zinvolve #zdifficult
#ztradeoffs #zthat #zdo #znot #zalways #zallow #za #zwin-win #zresult.
4. Discussion #zof #zethics #zissues #zfocuses #zon #zcompany #zexamples. #zWhat #zpersonal #zethics #zmatter?
#zSurveys #zindicate #zthat #zmany #zstudents #zhave #zcheated #zin #zclasses #zone #zway #zor #zanother,
#zpad #ztheir #zresumes #zwhen #zseeking #zjobs, #zand #zhave #zimproperly #zdownloaded #zcopyrighted
#zmusic. #zDoes #zethics #z“begin #zat #zhome”?
Answer: #zIf #zethics #zis #zto #zbe #ztheoretical #zor #zapplied #zonly #zin #zformal #zsituations, #zthen #zit #zmeans #zlittle #zin
#zpractice.
© #z2022 #zCengage. #zAll #zRights #zReserved. #zMay #znot #zbe #zscanned, #zcopied #zor #zduplicated, #zor #zposted #zto #za 4
#zpublicly #zaccessible
website, #zin #zwhole #zor #zin #zpart.
