, PLEASE USE THIS DOCUMENT AS A GUIDE TO ANSWER YOUR ASSIGNMENT
The Nature and Extent of Extortion in Marikana: A Qualitative Research Approach
1. Introduction
The violent incident at the Marikana informal settlement in Philippi East, which resulted in the tragic
deaths of seven individuals and has been linked by police to extortion activities, underscores a
profound and complex social crisis (Masilela, 2026). Understanding such a phenomenon requires
more than just statistical data; it demands a deep exploration into the lived experiences, motivations,
and social dynamics that fuel this violence. It is within this context that the UNISA Department of
Criminology and Security Science has proposed a qualitative research study, to be conducted with
the very detectives tasked with investigating these crimes.
This essay will critically discuss the fundamental characteristics of qualitative research, paying
particular attention to its overarching purpose, by applying the principles and context of the
Marikana extortion case study. By defining key concepts and outlining the core tenets of qualitative
inquiry, this discussion will demonstrate why this methodological approach is uniquely suited to
unravel the complex nature and extent of extortion in this specific community.
2. Definition of Key Concepts
It is first necessary to define the central concepts underpinning this research. Qualitative research is
an umbrella term for a methodological approach that seeks to understand the meaning individuals or
groups ascribe to a social or human problem (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Unlike quantitative research,
which focuses on measurement and statistical analysis, qualitative research prioritizes depth over
breadth, exploring the 'how' and 'why' of human behaviour, experience, and social interaction in
naturalistic settings.
The specific phenomena under investigation in this proposed study are the nature and extent of
extortion. In this context, the nature of extortion refers to its fundamental character and qualities.
This includes exploring the various forms it takes—from protection rackets and debt collection to
coercion for business opportunities—as well as the relationships between the perpetrators, the
victims, and the wider community. It also involves understanding the modus operandi of the
extortionists, the power dynamics at play, and the symbolic meanings attached to the violence, such
as the midnight shooting described in the case study (Masilela, 2026). Investigating the nature of
extortion means delving into the social and psychological fabric of the crime.
Conversely, the extent of extortion refers to its scope, scale, and pervasiveness within the Marikana
informal settlement. While quantitative methods might measure this by counting reported incidents,
a qualitative exploration of its 'extent' seeks to understand how deeply embedded the practice is in
the community. This involves exploring the perceived reach of extortionists, the sectors of the
community most affected (e.g., spaza shop owners, taxi operators), the frequency with which
residents encounter threats, and the overall climate of fear or normalisation that may have taken hold.
It is about understanding the phenomenon's reach not just numerically, but in terms of its impact on
daily life and social order. Understanding these concepts through a qualitative lens is essential for
developing effective and contextually relevant interventions.
The Nature and Extent of Extortion in Marikana: A Qualitative Research Approach
1. Introduction
The violent incident at the Marikana informal settlement in Philippi East, which resulted in the tragic
deaths of seven individuals and has been linked by police to extortion activities, underscores a
profound and complex social crisis (Masilela, 2026). Understanding such a phenomenon requires
more than just statistical data; it demands a deep exploration into the lived experiences, motivations,
and social dynamics that fuel this violence. It is within this context that the UNISA Department of
Criminology and Security Science has proposed a qualitative research study, to be conducted with
the very detectives tasked with investigating these crimes.
This essay will critically discuss the fundamental characteristics of qualitative research, paying
particular attention to its overarching purpose, by applying the principles and context of the
Marikana extortion case study. By defining key concepts and outlining the core tenets of qualitative
inquiry, this discussion will demonstrate why this methodological approach is uniquely suited to
unravel the complex nature and extent of extortion in this specific community.
2. Definition of Key Concepts
It is first necessary to define the central concepts underpinning this research. Qualitative research is
an umbrella term for a methodological approach that seeks to understand the meaning individuals or
groups ascribe to a social or human problem (Creswell & Poth, 2018). Unlike quantitative research,
which focuses on measurement and statistical analysis, qualitative research prioritizes depth over
breadth, exploring the 'how' and 'why' of human behaviour, experience, and social interaction in
naturalistic settings.
The specific phenomena under investigation in this proposed study are the nature and extent of
extortion. In this context, the nature of extortion refers to its fundamental character and qualities.
This includes exploring the various forms it takes—from protection rackets and debt collection to
coercion for business opportunities—as well as the relationships between the perpetrators, the
victims, and the wider community. It also involves understanding the modus operandi of the
extortionists, the power dynamics at play, and the symbolic meanings attached to the violence, such
as the midnight shooting described in the case study (Masilela, 2026). Investigating the nature of
extortion means delving into the social and psychological fabric of the crime.
Conversely, the extent of extortion refers to its scope, scale, and pervasiveness within the Marikana
informal settlement. While quantitative methods might measure this by counting reported incidents,
a qualitative exploration of its 'extent' seeks to understand how deeply embedded the practice is in
the community. This involves exploring the perceived reach of extortionists, the sectors of the
community most affected (e.g., spaza shop owners, taxi operators), the frequency with which
residents encounter threats, and the overall climate of fear or normalisation that may have taken hold.
It is about understanding the phenomenon's reach not just numerically, but in terms of its impact on
daily life and social order. Understanding these concepts through a qualitative lens is essential for
developing effective and contextually relevant interventions.
