PVL3701 Assignment 1 (COMPLETE ANSWERS) Semester 1 2026 - DUE March 2026

PVL3701 Assignment 1 (COMPLETE ANSWERS) Semester 1 2026 - DUE March 2026; 100% TRUSTED Complete, trusted solutions and explanations. For assistance, Whats-App 0.8.1..2.7.8..3.3.7.2... Against this background, consider the following set of facts: Thandi owns a hotel called “Imbizo Lodge” in Durban. She bought three new fridges for the kitchen from Value Save Traders (Pty) Ltd, in terms of a credit agreement. ValueSave Traders (Pty) Ltd reserves ownership of the fridges until the final instalment has been paid. Thandi also owes First Metro Bank R500 000. The debt is secured by a mortgage bond registered over the hotel. A guest of the hotel, Annie, accidentally packed a towel that looked like her own into her suitcase, honestly believing that it was hers, before leaving the hotel. One of the hotel’s chefs, Sipho, asked Thandi whether he could rent one of the small rooms in the hotel for a period of six months. Thandi agreed, and they concluded a lease agreement. Sipho also asked Thandi to borrow R5 000. They agreed that Sipho would pledge his cell phone as security for the loan. Thandi paid the R5 000 into Sipho’s bank account, but both parties agreed that it would not make sense for Sipho to hand the cell phone to Thandi. Thandi stated that she 6 trusted Sipho and believed that he would repay the money. A serious dispute later arose between Thandi and Sipho, and their relationship deteriorated. Sipho took a few days’ leave. While Sipho was away, Thandi changed the lock of Sipho’s room, removed his belongings and placed them in a storeroom. When Sipho returned, he discovered he could not access his room. He became extremely angry and set Thandi’s car on fire. He then broke into the storeroom and the room he had rented from Thandi, damaging the locks and doors of both rooms in the process. Sipho also kicked one of the fridges Thandi had purchased from Value Save Traders (Pty) Ltd, damaging it severely. Thandi contacted the private security company responsible for the hotel's security. Sipho later approached his friend, Daniel, a law student, for advice. Daniel advised Sipho to institute rei vindicatio against Thandi to recover his belongings and the control he previously exercised over the rented room. Question 1 Identify one person in the above set of facts that can be described as a “lawful holder”. In your answer, specifically refer to the relevant thing(s) of which he/she is a lawful holder. (3) [Your answer should not exceed 4 lines.] Evaluation criteria Not achieved Partially achieved Achieved Correct identification of a lawful holder and the thing over which the lawful holder has lawful holdership. 0 1 2 Correct reference. N/A N/A 1 Question 2 Briefly describe Annie’s real relationship with the towel in her suitcase. In your answer, refer to the mental element. (3) [Your answer should not exceed 4 lines.] 7 Evaluation criteria Not achieved Partially achieved Achieved Correct identification of Annie’s real relationship and the mental element present. 0 1 2 Correct reference. N/A N/A 1 Question 3 How would you describe Annie’s real relationship with the towel if she had stolen the towel? In your answer, refer to the mental element. (3) [Your answer should not exceed 4 lines.] Evaluation criteria Not achieved Partially achieved Achieved Correct identification of the party’s real relationship and the mental element present. 0 1 2 Correct reference. N/A N/A 1 Question 4 Briefly explain who holds a personal right against Thandi. (4) [Your answer should not exceed 4 lines.] Evaluation criteria Not achieved Partially achieved Achieved Correct identification of the person(s) that holds a personal right against Thandi. 0 1-2 3 Correct reference. N/A N/A 1 Question 5 Which remedy is available to Thandi regarding the damaged locks of the room that Sipho rented and the doors of the storeroom