QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
◉ While hybrid plans come in several different types and plan
designed, each is considered either a defined benefit or a defined
contribution plan for the purposes of tax qualification. Answer:
While hybrid plans come in several different types and plan
designed, each is considered either a defined benefit or a defined
contribution plan for the purposes of tax qualification.
◉ What factors should be considered in designing a hybrid
retirement plan? Answer: (a) workforce demographics and mobility
(b) employee attitudes toward current retirement benefits
(c) relative levels of benefits and rates of benefit accrual
(d) cost constraints for the plan sponsor
(e) certain other items, such as awareness of the legal, regulatory
and public relations environment of hybrid plans. These are
especially important since plan sponsors have been criticized for the
negative effects of benefit accruals or values for certain groups of
plan participants upon conversion to a hybrid plan. This criticism of
plan sponsors has at times resulted in costly litigation.
◉ Describe what features defined benefit hybrid plans possess that
are characteristic of traditional defined benefit plans. Answer: These
plans promise a specific benefit level for participation and plan
, sponsors manage the investing of plan assets through commingled
funds. Hence, the plan sponsor bears the investment risk and reaps
the benefit of investment rewards. Defined benefit hybrid plan
structures make it relatively easy for plan sponsors to integrate the
plan with social security and target income replacement ratios.
These plans offer distributions in the form of annuities and are
subject to ERISA requirements such as minimum standards for
eligibility, vesting, and funding. Annual actuarial valuations are
required, as is payment of plan termination insurance premiums to
the PBGC.
◉ Describe what features these plans possess that are typically
associated with defined contribution plan structures. Answer:
Defined benefit hybrid plans also possess certain features that are
characteristic of traditional defined contribution plans. In addition
to allowing for distribution of benefits in an annuity form, defined
benefit hybrid plans also offer lump sums as a distribution option.
This feature which makes for portability and benefits expressed in
terms of lump-sum values typically makes these hybrids of greater
appeal to younger and more mobile workers.
◉ What is a cash balance plan? Answer: A cash balance plan is a
defined benefit hybrid retirement plan where the sponsor typically
makes plan contributions based on a specified formula that provides
annual contribution credit and applies a fixed interest rate credit.
Although this is the typical cash balance design, there can be
variations on this benefit design. Some variations include: