LECTURE 1: INTRODUCTION & SPECIMEN ISSUES
- Toxicology study of harmful interactions between substances and biological
systems.
What is forensic toxicology
A specialization of human toxicology. ‘the application of toxicology for the
purposes of the law’
- Forensic toxicology is part of forensic medicine:
Forensic pathology
Forensic toxicology
Forensic anthropology
Forensic odontology
Where is forensic toxicology applied
- Criminal law:
(fatal) poisoning
Overdose
Drink & drive
Were drugs taken
- Civil law:
Exposure to harmful substances in the workplace
Error in medical treatment
- Doping in sports:
Did the athlete use banned substances
Difference between medical and forensic tox/drug testing
- Medical:
Patient consent not required.
Identity of specimen is presumed.
Screening result is sufficient for medical decision.
Analyte is known.
Results are used for medical evaluation.
- Forensic:
Legal basis for testing of subject / subject must consent to be tested.
Identity of specimen must be proved (“chain of custody”)
Only confirmed results can be considered positive (“confirmation of
molecular structure”)
Analyte is not known (“screen first”)
Results are used for legal action.
What is examined in a forensic toxicology case
- Investigation of: poisoning deaths, poisoning of the living, forensic drug testing.
- Occupational applications: enforcement of legal exposure limits, to ensure safe
water air and food.
Components of a forensic toxicology case
- Case history:
, Context, evidence collected at crime scene.
Bottles, pill, powders, trace residue, available chemicals.
To narrow the search.
- Analytical determinations
Chemical and biomarkers
That’s your job find the best analysis to answer the toxicological
questions in a case.
- Toxicological interpretation
- And presentation of results.
Toxic issue and death
Toxicological questions to be answered
- Was death of illness due to a poison?
- What toxin produced the illness?
- Was the substance employed capable of producing death?
- Was a sufficient quantity taken to produce death or toxic results?
- When and how was the toxin taken?
- May a poisoning have occurred and the poison either be or have become
undetectable?
, - Could the detected poison have an origin other than the poisoning?
- Was the poisoning SUICIDAL, ACCIDENTAL or HOMICIDAL?
- Were the correct specimens collected and preserved, analyzed in such a manner
to answer the question at hand?
SPECIMEN
Why are these samples analyzed?
To obtain qualitative and quantitative information on the presence of harmful/
banned substances.
Qualitative: absent or present? Identity of poison/ drug.
Quantitative: how much? Dose.
- The results will help the toxicologist to interpret:
Physiological effects (at time of crime)
Behavioural effects (at time of crime)
What kind of samples (specimen) are examined in forensic toxicology
- Biological samples: blood, urine, oral fluid, gastric/ bowel content, eye fluid
(vitreous humor), sweat, breath, hair, nails, bile, lung, brain, liver, kidney, bone …
- Exhibits (from crime scene/ ante mortem): food and drinks, glasses and plates,
syringes, needles.
- Medication / drugs.
Urine
- Produces by the kidneys.
- Blood filtration by the kidneys.
- Stored in the bladder until voided – collect from bladder.
- Many drugs and metabolites are present at higher concentrations in urine that in
blood.
Bile
- Digestive secretion.
- Continuously produced by the liver.
- Stored in the gallbladder.
- Certain drugs can be concentrate in the bile.
Qualitative – the presence of a drug in the urine/ bile of an individual indicates that some
time prior to death the drug of poison was present in the blood of the individual.
Vitreous humour
- Fluid that occupies the space between the lens and the retina of the eye.
- Sequestered from putrefaction, charring and trauma, micro-organisms.
- Useful in cases where decomposition is advanced, body is exhumed or in fire
deaths.
- Limitation- blood:vitreous ratio may not be known.
Stomach contents
- Visual examination may reveal tablets.
- Drugs that have been orally ingested may be detected in stomach contents.
- Generally qualitative:
Stomach contents are not homogeneous.
Only a portion of stomach contents collected.
Useful for directing further analysis.
Post mortem blood