Who killed Barry? Deductive Reasoning Lab
https://www.crime-time.co.uk/redherring.html
As you play the game make sure to answer the questions below. Make sure to spend lots of time
clicking around. You will find clues (white circles), witnesses (red circles), and items called “Red
Herrings” which are just items and not clues (also white circles). You will also need to integrate the
witnesses. Each Witness has a section below for you to write what you interrogated them on. You do
not need to go in any particular order as long as you get them all. Please make sure that you write
on the Doc in different colors and please do not use black.
Background
Witness Name Information Connection to Why are they a Can they be
Learned victim? suspect? ruled out as the
killer? Why?
, Honor Shift Account Clerk at Boyfriend was Wallet full of No, the suspect
Spillers. Natural blackmailed by enough money had motive, no
aptitude for the victim. to make up for empathy
numbers. Andy Looted the victim the missing towards the
Syze is her body after money from the victim, and her
boyfriend. She finding it. suspects wallet. only alibi didn’t
saw Andy this Earings on the like the victim
morning. Out floor next to the either.
with Goldie suspect's body.
Crumm last Not sad the
night. Admitted suspect is dead.
to looting the
victim's body for
money. Gave
her boyfriend
Andy Syze two
jumpers.
Suggested Andy
and her tell John
Dory about the
suspect
blackmailing
Andy.
Alexandra Dock Bright and Victim ex- She was told the Yes because
Chatty, girlfriend barry was two she seemed
Alexandra is timing very attached to
popular with the the victim and
customers and didn't believe
has many that barry was
admirers cheating, also
was at the
ironmonger and
sold an axe to
John Dory
Goldie Crumm Out with Honor Was one of the Ex-girlfriend of No, her only alibi
Shift last night. suspects' ex- suspect. Didn't is Shift, could be
Ex-girlfriend of girlfriends. like the suspect. covering for her.
suspect.
Ava Nother Told John Dory, Mother of one of Mother of the Yes,the suspect
the victim had the victims ex- victim's ex- is in her later
two girlfriends girlfriends, Paula girlfriend. years, most
lately and one of Nother. likely doesn't
them was her have the
https://www.crime-time.co.uk/redherring.html
As you play the game make sure to answer the questions below. Make sure to spend lots of time
clicking around. You will find clues (white circles), witnesses (red circles), and items called “Red
Herrings” which are just items and not clues (also white circles). You will also need to integrate the
witnesses. Each Witness has a section below for you to write what you interrogated them on. You do
not need to go in any particular order as long as you get them all. Please make sure that you write
on the Doc in different colors and please do not use black.
Background
Witness Name Information Connection to Why are they a Can they be
Learned victim? suspect? ruled out as the
killer? Why?
, Honor Shift Account Clerk at Boyfriend was Wallet full of No, the suspect
Spillers. Natural blackmailed by enough money had motive, no
aptitude for the victim. to make up for empathy
numbers. Andy Looted the victim the missing towards the
Syze is her body after money from the victim, and her
boyfriend. She finding it. suspects wallet. only alibi didn’t
saw Andy this Earings on the like the victim
morning. Out floor next to the either.
with Goldie suspect's body.
Crumm last Not sad the
night. Admitted suspect is dead.
to looting the
victim's body for
money. Gave
her boyfriend
Andy Syze two
jumpers.
Suggested Andy
and her tell John
Dory about the
suspect
blackmailing
Andy.
Alexandra Dock Bright and Victim ex- She was told the Yes because
Chatty, girlfriend barry was two she seemed
Alexandra is timing very attached to
popular with the the victim and
customers and didn't believe
has many that barry was
admirers cheating, also
was at the
ironmonger and
sold an axe to
John Dory
Goldie Crumm Out with Honor Was one of the Ex-girlfriend of No, her only alibi
Shift last night. suspects' ex- suspect. Didn't is Shift, could be
Ex-girlfriend of girlfriends. like the suspect. covering for her.
suspect.
Ava Nother Told John Dory, Mother of one of Mother of the Yes,the suspect
the victim had the victims ex- victim's ex- is in her later
two girlfriends girlfriends, Paula girlfriend. years, most
lately and one of Nother. likely doesn't
them was her have the
