holiday. While he is enjoying the sea air, two men—an older, tough man and his
son—approach him. They angrily accuse him of being someone they know, a
man who left a woman named Nancy heartbroken after disappearing for four
years. Even though Mr. Carter tries to explain that they have the wrong person,
the men are sure they’ve found the right guy. The older man threatens to hurt
him, but the son talks him into staying calm. Mr. Carter, feeling worried, agrees
to go with them to meet the woman and clear up the misunderstanding.
As they walk back to town, Carter becomes more and more nervous,
afraid of how Nancy will react if she also thinks he’s the man who left her. His
attempts to prove his innocence are ignored by the two men, who are convinced
they’ve caught the right person. On the way, an old boatman even greets Carter,
which makes the men more certain he’s the missing man.
They arrive at a small house, and Carter is taken inside to wait. The son,
Jim, tells his sister Nancy that they’ve brought the man they were looking for.
Carter, worried, looks around the house. When Nancy finally comes down the
stairs, she immediately says that Carter is not her former lover, Bert Simmons.
Her father and brother are shocked, but Nancy is sure. She points out that Bert
had a "beautiful nose" and was much more handsome than Mr. Carter.
Carter, feeling relieved, tries to leave, but at the last minute, he changes his
mind. He boldly claims that he really is Bert Simmons and that he winked at
Nancy earlier as a signal for her to pretend not to recognize him. To his surprise,
Nancy strongly denies this, saying she has never seen him before. But her father
and brother are convinced by Mr. Carter’s confidence and decide to accept him
as Bert.
Nancy is angry and protests, but her family doesn’t listen. They think Mr. Carter
is Bert and that he only denied it at first to avoid trouble. Nancy’s father, Mr.
Evans, insists that Mr. Carter stay with them, and they take his money and
belongings to stop him from running away again.