AQA A-LEVEL LAW Paper 3B Human Rights 71623B Combined Question Paper and Mark Scheme

Pleasefwritefclearlyfinfblockfcapitals.

Centrefnumber Candidatefnumber


f
Surname
f
Forename(s)
f
Candidatefsignat ure
Ifdeclarefthisfisfmyfownfwork.



A-level
LAW
Paper 3B Human Rights
f f f




Monday 15 June 2020
f f f Afternoon Time allowed: 2 hours
f f f




Materials
ForfExaminer’sfUse
 Youfwillfneedfnofotherfmaterials.
Question Mark
Instructions 1–5
 Usefblackfinkforfblackfball-pointfpen.
 Fillfinfthefboxesfatftheftopfoffthisfpage. 6
 Answerfallfquestions.fYoufmustfanswerfthefquestionsfinfthefspacesfpro 7
vided.f Dofnotfwritefonfblankfpages. 8
 Dofallfroughfworkfinfthisfbook.fCrossfthroughfanyfworkfyoufdofnotfwantftofbefm
9
arked.
 Iffyoufneedfextrafspacefforfyourfanswer(s),fuseftheflinedfpagesfatfthefendfoffthisfb 10
ook.f Writefthefquestionfnumberfagainstfyourfanswer(s). 11
 Questionsfshouldfbefansweredfinfcontinuousfprose.fGivefreasonedfans
TOTAL
wers.fWherefappropriate,fmakefreferenceftofcases,fstatutesfandfexamp
les.

Information
 Thefmarksfforfquestionsfarefshownfinfbrackets.
 Thefmaximumfmarkfforfthisfpaperfisf100.




*JUN2071623 f 01* IB/G/Jun20/E5
7162/3B

, 2
Dofnotfwritef
outsidefthe
Answerfallfquestionsfinfthefspacesfprovided. box




Onlyfonefanswerfperfquestionfisfallowed.

Forfeachfquestionfcompletelyffillfinfthefcirclefalongsidefthefappropriatefanswer.

CORRECTfMETHOD WRONGfMETHODS


Iffyoufwantftofchangefyourfanswerfyoufmustfcrossfoutfyourforiginalfanswerfasfshown.

Iffyoufwishftofreturnftofanfanswerfpreviouslyfcrossedfout,fringfthefanswerfyoufnowfwishftofselectfasfshow
n.



0 1 SelectftheffalsefstatementfaboutfArticlef2foffthefEuropeanfConventionfonfHumanfRightsf(thef
rightftoflife).
[1fmark]

A Articlef2fdoesfnotfcreatefafrightftofdie.

B Articlef2fmayfrequirefthefStateftofprotectfitsfcitizensffromfen
vironmentalfrisksftoflife.

C Articlef2fpermitsfkillingfbyfagentsfoffthefState,fsuchfasfthefpolice,fwhenf
theyfbelievefitftofbefreasonable.

D Articlef2frequiresfindependentfinvestigationfoffdeathsfwhichfoccurfbe
causefoffthefactionsfoffagentsfoffthefState,fsuchfasfthefpolice.



0 2 SelectftheftruefstatementfaboutfvariousfaspectsfoffthefEuropeanfConventionfonfHumanfRig
htsf(ECHR)fandfthefEuropeanfCourtfoffHumanfRightsf(ECtHR).
[1fmark]

A AfgovernmentfministerfresponsiblefforfafBillfinfParliamentfmustfpublis
hfafstatementfindicatingfwhetherfafBillfisfcompatiblefwithfthefECHR.


B Afperson’sfreputationfcannotfbefprotectedfunderfthefECHR.

C JudgesfapplyingfcommonflawfinfEnglishfcourtsfcanfignorefthefEC
HR.

D OnlyfStatesfcanfbringfactionsfinfthefECtHR.




*02*
IB/G/Jun20/7162/3B

, 3
Dofnotfwritef
outsidefthef
0 3 Selectftheftruefstatementfaboutfjudgesfinfcriminalfcases. box

[1fmark]

A CourtfoffAppealfjudgesfhearfsomefappealsfsittingfwithfDistrictfJu
dgesf(Magistrates’fCourts).

B CrownfCourtfjudgesfhearfsomefappeals.

C Districtfjudgesf(Magistrates’fCourts)fsitfwithfjuriesftoftryfcases.

D SupremefCourtfjudgesftryfsomefcasesfandfhearfappealsfonfissuesfoffl
awfonfothers.



0 4 Selectftheffalsefstatementfaboutfthefindependencefoffthefjudiciary.
[1fmark]

A Itfisfdifficultftofremovefsuperiorfjudgesffromfoffice.

B Judgesfcannotfbefsuedfforftheirfdecisionsfinfcases,fevenfifftheyfma
kefmistakes.

C Judgesfdofnotftakefpartfinfcasesfinfwhichftheyfhavefanyfpersonalfinte
rest.

D ThefLordfChancellorfisfthefonlyfgovernmentfministerfallowedftofinfl
uencefthefdecisionfoffafjudgefinfafcase.



0 5 Delegatedflegislationfinfthefformfoffstatutoryfinstrumentsfisfsubjectftofvariousfcontrols.fSel
ectftheftruefstatementfaboutfcontrolsfonfstatutoryfinstruments.
[1fmark]

A Afcourtfcanfrewritefafstatutoryfinstrumentfiffitfdecidesfthatfitfwasfissu
edfbeyondfthefpowersfavailableftofthefminister.

B Afstatutoryfinstrumentfissuedfbyfaflocalfcouncilfhasftofbefapprovedfbyfaf
governmentfminister.

C ManyfstatutoryfinstrumentsfbecomeflawfunlessfParliamentfvotesftofrej
ectfthemfwithinfafspecifiedftimef(usuallyf40fdays)foffbeingfissued.


D ThefScrutinyfCommitteefhasfthefpowerftofstopfanyfproposedfsta
tutoryfinstrumentffromfbecomingflaw. 5




Turnfoverf►


*03*
IB/G/Jun20/7162/3B