BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
Step 1: Set the scene
Looking at pictures from the DRC cobalt mines where kids are engaged in labor is really heart-
wrenching. Pictures depict kids working under hazardous and unsafe conditions, with little to no
safety gear, which exposes them to physical and emotional damage. It tugs one's heart to see the
extent of exploitation and how much it impacts these children, especially when their futures are so
adversely affected by these harsh circumstances.
Step 2
1.Which is the most likely utilitarian option in the multiple-choice question above?
The most probable utilitarian option is C: "This is just a fact of global supply chains and necessary for
global economic growth, which is in everyone's best interest."
2: Why do you say this?
Premise 1: The DRC cobalt mines form the backbone of the global supply chain due to cobalt's
presence as a key ingredient in emerging technologies like electric vehicle batteries and electronics.
Premise 2: Access to cheap and abundant raw materials like cobalt fuels the global economy and
accelerates economic development and technological advancements.
Premise 3: Utilitarianism holds that the greatest good should be done for the greatest number, and in
this case the economic and technological benefits of mining cobalt would be greater than the harm
done by child labour.
3.What do you feel about this option?
Even if the utilitarian practice may suggest that the economic benefit is more important than the
exploitation, I do not agree. The fact that human rights must be sacrificed to achieve economic
progress is unethical. No amount of economic growth is worth the children's suffering and
exploitation. Such an argument is ethically unsound since it is failing to take into consideration the
welfare and rights of the subjects that get affected along the way.
4: What choice did you make?
D: "I wonder who is profiting out of this?"
I find this option appealing because it brings to light the systemic nature of the problems involved in
exploiting child labour in the DRC. It points to the question of who gains from this inhumane practice
and to the necessity of responsibility and change within industries that benefit from such exploitative
means
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
BOOK UNQUE DOCUMENT ON WHATSAPP 0645167275
Step 1: Set the scene
Looking at pictures from the DRC cobalt mines where kids are engaged in labor is really heart-
wrenching. Pictures depict kids working under hazardous and unsafe conditions, with little to no
safety gear, which exposes them to physical and emotional damage. It tugs one's heart to see the
extent of exploitation and how much it impacts these children, especially when their futures are so
adversely affected by these harsh circumstances.
Step 2
1.Which is the most likely utilitarian option in the multiple-choice question above?
The most probable utilitarian option is C: "This is just a fact of global supply chains and necessary for
global economic growth, which is in everyone's best interest."
2: Why do you say this?
Premise 1: The DRC cobalt mines form the backbone of the global supply chain due to cobalt's
presence as a key ingredient in emerging technologies like electric vehicle batteries and electronics.
Premise 2: Access to cheap and abundant raw materials like cobalt fuels the global economy and
accelerates economic development and technological advancements.
Premise 3: Utilitarianism holds that the greatest good should be done for the greatest number, and in
this case the economic and technological benefits of mining cobalt would be greater than the harm
done by child labour.
3.What do you feel about this option?
Even if the utilitarian practice may suggest that the economic benefit is more important than the
exploitation, I do not agree. The fact that human rights must be sacrificed to achieve economic
progress is unethical. No amount of economic growth is worth the children's suffering and
exploitation. Such an argument is ethically unsound since it is failing to take into consideration the
welfare and rights of the subjects that get affected along the way.
4: What choice did you make?
D: "I wonder who is profiting out of this?"
I find this option appealing because it brings to light the systemic nature of the problems involved in
exploiting child labour in the DRC. It points to the question of who gains from this inhumane practice
and to the necessity of responsibility and change within industries that benefit from such exploitative
means
