LAW 122 Test | Questions and Answers | New
2025/2026 Update | With Complete Solutions
Who were the judges in Robson v Hallett
Lord Parker CJ, Diplock LJ, Ashworth J
What is the remedy being sought by Thomas and Dennis Robson?
To have their remaining convictions against Sgt. McCaffrey dropped.
What were the issues in Robson v Hallett?
1. Were the police officers trespassing ab initio?
2. Was Sgt. McCaffrey trespassing after he was told to leave by Mr. Robson?
3. Were the two remaining officers trespassing when they entered into the premises to help Sgt.
McCaffrey?
What were the ratios of Robson v Hallett?
1. Any member of the public has implied licence to enter a property and walk up to the front
door for the purpose of communicating with the occupier, provided it is on lawful business.
2. A person must be given a reasonable time to leave after their licence is revoked before they
can be considered to be trespassing?
3. A police officer may enter a premises without express licence when they see a breach of peace
and are acting in their duty to stop it.
What did Diplock LJ say about extinguishing the implied licence?
It can be distinguished at any time by a sign or by express licence.
, What were the two cases that were distinguished in R v H, and what was the case that was
followed?
Distinguished: Davis v Lisle, Grand Central Railway Co. v Bates
Followed: McArdle v Wallace
Who was the judge of Davis v Lisle and what did they say in regards to revocation of a
licence?
Goddard J - That asserting your right to stay after having your licence revoked could make you
liable for trespass.
Who were the judges of Howden v MoT and what court was it in?
Cooke P, Bisson J and Somers J.
Court of Appeal.
Which judge said that "there must be limits to an implied licence"?
Cooke P in Howden
What were the issues in Howden?
Whether the traffic officer was trespassing at the time in which he requested that Mr. Howden
undergo a breath alcohol test.
Sub-issue 1: Whether the appellant had been stopped by the traffic officer under any statutory
powers.
Sub-issue 2: Whether the traffic officer was entitled to enter private property for the purpose of
enforcing any of his statutory powers.
What was the decision of Payn?
2025/2026 Update | With Complete Solutions
Who were the judges in Robson v Hallett
Lord Parker CJ, Diplock LJ, Ashworth J
What is the remedy being sought by Thomas and Dennis Robson?
To have their remaining convictions against Sgt. McCaffrey dropped.
What were the issues in Robson v Hallett?
1. Were the police officers trespassing ab initio?
2. Was Sgt. McCaffrey trespassing after he was told to leave by Mr. Robson?
3. Were the two remaining officers trespassing when they entered into the premises to help Sgt.
McCaffrey?
What were the ratios of Robson v Hallett?
1. Any member of the public has implied licence to enter a property and walk up to the front
door for the purpose of communicating with the occupier, provided it is on lawful business.
2. A person must be given a reasonable time to leave after their licence is revoked before they
can be considered to be trespassing?
3. A police officer may enter a premises without express licence when they see a breach of peace
and are acting in their duty to stop it.
What did Diplock LJ say about extinguishing the implied licence?
It can be distinguished at any time by a sign or by express licence.
, What were the two cases that were distinguished in R v H, and what was the case that was
followed?
Distinguished: Davis v Lisle, Grand Central Railway Co. v Bates
Followed: McArdle v Wallace
Who was the judge of Davis v Lisle and what did they say in regards to revocation of a
licence?
Goddard J - That asserting your right to stay after having your licence revoked could make you
liable for trespass.
Who were the judges of Howden v MoT and what court was it in?
Cooke P, Bisson J and Somers J.
Court of Appeal.
Which judge said that "there must be limits to an implied licence"?
Cooke P in Howden
What were the issues in Howden?
Whether the traffic officer was trespassing at the time in which he requested that Mr. Howden
undergo a breath alcohol test.
Sub-issue 1: Whether the appellant had been stopped by the traffic officer under any statutory
powers.
Sub-issue 2: Whether the traffic officer was entitled to enter private property for the purpose of
enforcing any of his statutory powers.
What was the decision of Payn?
