Samenvatting tentamen politieke arena’s: stad, staat, imperia.
,Inhoud
Week 1 – The State and Its Powers in Historical Perspective.................................................................5
1. Max Weber – Politics as a Vocation (1919).....................................................................................5
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................5
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................5
2. Andreas Anter – The Modern State and Its Monopoly on Violence (2019)....................................5
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................5
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................5
3. Michael Mann – The Autonomous Power of the State: Its Origins, Mechanisms and Results
(1984).................................................................................................................................................6
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................6
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................6
4. Charles S. Maier – The Project-State and Its Rivals (2023, pp. 1–18)..............................................7
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................7
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................7
Samenvattend overzicht – Week 1.....................................................................................................7
Week 2 – States and Empires.................................................................................................................9
1. Charles Tilly – Cities and the Rise of States in Europe, A.D. 1000–1800.........................................9
Centrale stelling..............................................................................................................................9
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................9
2. Hendrik Spruyt – The Sovereign State and Its Competitors (1994).................................................9
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................9
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................9
3. Tilly vs. Spruyt...............................................................................................................................10
4. Curtis Murphy – From Citizens to Subjects: City, State, and the Enlightenment in Poland,
Ukraine, and Belarus.........................................................................................................................10
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................10
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................10
5. Prak – Burghers into Citizens: Urban and National Citizenship in the Netherlands during the
Revolutionary Era.............................................................................................................................10
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................10
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................11
6. Overkoepelende thema’s – Week 2..............................................................................................11
Modelantwoorden per vraag (slides)...................................................................................................11
Groepsopdracht II – Tilly...............................................................................................................11
Groepsopdracht III – Spruyt..........................................................................................................11
, Groepsopdracht IV – Tilly vs. Spruyt.............................................................................................12
Groepsopdracht I – Murphy.........................................................................................................12
Groepsopdracht II – Prak..............................................................................................................12
Week 3 – States and Empires...............................................................................................................13
Wat zijn imperia?..............................................................................................................................13
Imperia vergeleken met territoriale staten en stadsstaten..............................................................13
1. Burbank & Cooper – Empires in World History (2010).................................................................13
2. Barkey – Empire of Difference: The Ottomans in Comparative Perspective (2008)......................13
3. Wilson – Still a Monstrosity? Reflections on Early Modern German Statehood (2006)................14
4. Atul Kohli – Imperialism and the Developing World (2020)..........................................................14
5. J.A. Hobson – Imperialism: A Study (1902)...................................................................................14
Groepsopdrachten en modelantwoorden........................................................................................14
1. “Repertoires of power” (Burbank & Cooper)............................................................................15
2. “Politics of difference”..............................................................................................................15
3. Imperia en natiestaten..............................................................................................................15
4. Discussie: Is de Europese Unie een empire?.............................................................................15
Overkoepelende inzichten week 3...................................................................................................15
Week 4: John Breuilly – “Nationalism and National Unification in 19th-Century Europe” (2013)........16
Jürgen Osterhammel – The Transformation of the World (2014), p. 403–419.................................16
🏛️
Krishan Kumar – “Nation-States as Empires, Empires as Nation-States” (2010) .........................16
Tentamensamenvatting................................................................................................................17
Week 5 – Totalitarianism: Stalinism and Nazism Compared.................................................................18
Week 6: De Verzorgingsstaat: Ontstaan, Typologieën en Toekomst....................................................21
1. William Beveridge (1942) – Social Insurance and Allied Services..............................................21
2. Friedrich Hayek (1945) – The Road to Serfdom........................................................................21
3. Peter Baldwin (1992) – “The Welfare State for Historians”......................................................21
4. Gøsta Esping-Andersen (1990) – The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism..............................22
5. Paul Pierson (1998) – “Irresistible Forces, Immovable Objects”...............................................22
6. Cook & Dimitrov (2017) – “The Social Contract Revisited”.......................................................23
Samenvattend overzicht...............................................................................................................23
Week 7:................................................................................................................................................25
1. Natasha Wheatley – The Life and Death of States: Central Europe and the Transformation of
Modern Sovereignty (2023, pp. 255–289)........................................................................................25
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................25
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................25
2. Charles S. Maier – The Project-State and Its Rivals (2023, pp. 360–392)......................................25
,Inhoud
Week 1 – The State and Its Powers in Historical Perspective.................................................................5
1. Max Weber – Politics as a Vocation (1919).....................................................................................5
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................5
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................5
2. Andreas Anter – The Modern State and Its Monopoly on Violence (2019)....................................5
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................5
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................5
3. Michael Mann – The Autonomous Power of the State: Its Origins, Mechanisms and Results
(1984).................................................................................................................................................6
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................6
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................6
4. Charles S. Maier – The Project-State and Its Rivals (2023, pp. 1–18)..............................................7
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................7
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................7
Samenvattend overzicht – Week 1.....................................................................................................7
Week 2 – States and Empires.................................................................................................................9
1. Charles Tilly – Cities and the Rise of States in Europe, A.D. 1000–1800.........................................9
Centrale stelling..............................................................................................................................9
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................9
2. Hendrik Spruyt – The Sovereign State and Its Competitors (1994).................................................9
Kernidee.........................................................................................................................................9
Belangrijkste punten.......................................................................................................................9
3. Tilly vs. Spruyt...............................................................................................................................10
4. Curtis Murphy – From Citizens to Subjects: City, State, and the Enlightenment in Poland,
Ukraine, and Belarus.........................................................................................................................10
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................10
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................10
5. Prak – Burghers into Citizens: Urban and National Citizenship in the Netherlands during the
Revolutionary Era.............................................................................................................................10
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................10
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................11
6. Overkoepelende thema’s – Week 2..............................................................................................11
Modelantwoorden per vraag (slides)...................................................................................................11
Groepsopdracht II – Tilly...............................................................................................................11
Groepsopdracht III – Spruyt..........................................................................................................11
, Groepsopdracht IV – Tilly vs. Spruyt.............................................................................................12
Groepsopdracht I – Murphy.........................................................................................................12
Groepsopdracht II – Prak..............................................................................................................12
Week 3 – States and Empires...............................................................................................................13
Wat zijn imperia?..............................................................................................................................13
Imperia vergeleken met territoriale staten en stadsstaten..............................................................13
1. Burbank & Cooper – Empires in World History (2010).................................................................13
2. Barkey – Empire of Difference: The Ottomans in Comparative Perspective (2008)......................13
3. Wilson – Still a Monstrosity? Reflections on Early Modern German Statehood (2006)................14
4. Atul Kohli – Imperialism and the Developing World (2020)..........................................................14
5. J.A. Hobson – Imperialism: A Study (1902)...................................................................................14
Groepsopdrachten en modelantwoorden........................................................................................14
1. “Repertoires of power” (Burbank & Cooper)............................................................................15
2. “Politics of difference”..............................................................................................................15
3. Imperia en natiestaten..............................................................................................................15
4. Discussie: Is de Europese Unie een empire?.............................................................................15
Overkoepelende inzichten week 3...................................................................................................15
Week 4: John Breuilly – “Nationalism and National Unification in 19th-Century Europe” (2013)........16
Jürgen Osterhammel – The Transformation of the World (2014), p. 403–419.................................16
🏛️
Krishan Kumar – “Nation-States as Empires, Empires as Nation-States” (2010) .........................16
Tentamensamenvatting................................................................................................................17
Week 5 – Totalitarianism: Stalinism and Nazism Compared.................................................................18
Week 6: De Verzorgingsstaat: Ontstaan, Typologieën en Toekomst....................................................21
1. William Beveridge (1942) – Social Insurance and Allied Services..............................................21
2. Friedrich Hayek (1945) – The Road to Serfdom........................................................................21
3. Peter Baldwin (1992) – “The Welfare State for Historians”......................................................21
4. Gøsta Esping-Andersen (1990) – The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism..............................22
5. Paul Pierson (1998) – “Irresistible Forces, Immovable Objects”...............................................22
6. Cook & Dimitrov (2017) – “The Social Contract Revisited”.......................................................23
Samenvattend overzicht...............................................................................................................23
Week 7:................................................................................................................................................25
1. Natasha Wheatley – The Life and Death of States: Central Europe and the Transformation of
Modern Sovereignty (2023, pp. 255–289)........................................................................................25
Kernidee.......................................................................................................................................25
Belangrijkste punten.....................................................................................................................25
2. Charles S. Maier – The Project-State and Its Rivals (2023, pp. 360–392)......................................25
