, PLEASE USE THIS DOCUMENT AS A GUIDE ONLY
1. In this essay, you are required to do an in-depth exploration and critical examination of an
educational model or policy that has been transposed from one cultural or national context to
another. The analysis should incorporate a comprehensive justification for the selection and
adoption of said model or policy, emphasising the perceived benefits and anticipated
improvements in the recipient context. It is imperative to elucidate the modifications made to
tailor the model or policy to align with the specific socio-cultural, economic and educational
milieu of the host environment. Furthermore, the discourse should address the challenges and
obstacles encountered during the implementation phase, including financial and cultural
resistance. The attitudes and perceptions of the local populace towards the imported model or
policy must be meticulously documented, alongside an evaluation of its achievements and
shortcomings. The conclusion of the paper should propose a structured agenda for future
scholarly investigation, prioritising unresolved questions and potential areas for further study to
enhance the understanding and efficacy of such educational transplants.
The Chilean Experiment with School Vouchers: A Critical Examination of a Neoliberal
Educational Transplant from the United States
1. Introduction and Contextual Background
The global landscape of education is characterised by a continuous flow of policies, practices, and
ideologies across national borders. This phenomenon, often termed ‘educational borrowing’ or
‘policy lending’, has become a defining feature of contemporary comparative and international
education. Driven by forces of globalisation, international assessments such as the Programme for
International Student Assessment (PISA), and the agendas of supranational organisations like the
World Bank and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), nations
increasingly look beyond their own borders for solutions to perceived educational crises. However,
the transfer of educational models is not a neutral or straightforward process; it is deeply embedded
in political ideologies, economic imperatives, and cultural values. This essay undertakes an in-depth
exploration and critical examination of one of the most radical and contested educational transplants
of the late twentieth century: the introduction of a nationwide school voucher system in Chile, a
policy model borrowed from the United States.
The significance of this topic lies in its embodiment of pure neoliberal ideology applied to education.
In the early 1980s, the military dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet, advised by a group of
Chilean economists trained at the University of Chicago (the ‘Chicago Boys’), enacted a sweeping
decentralisation reform that included the establishment of a universal school voucher system. This
model was explicitly inspired by the work of American economist Milton Friedman, who first
proposed educational vouchers in his 1955 essay “The Role of Government in Education.” The
Chilean case offers a unique longitudinal laboratory: it is the oldest and most extensive national
voucher system in the world, now spanning over four decades. By examining the transfer of this
policy from its theoretical origins in the US to its brutal implementation in Pinochet’s Chile, this
essay will provide a comprehensive justification for its adoption, delineate the modifications made to
the model, analyse the challenges of implementation and local resistance, document local
perceptions, evaluate its successes and failures, and finally propose a structured agenda for future
scholarly investigation.
1. In this essay, you are required to do an in-depth exploration and critical examination of an
educational model or policy that has been transposed from one cultural or national context to
another. The analysis should incorporate a comprehensive justification for the selection and
adoption of said model or policy, emphasising the perceived benefits and anticipated
improvements in the recipient context. It is imperative to elucidate the modifications made to
tailor the model or policy to align with the specific socio-cultural, economic and educational
milieu of the host environment. Furthermore, the discourse should address the challenges and
obstacles encountered during the implementation phase, including financial and cultural
resistance. The attitudes and perceptions of the local populace towards the imported model or
policy must be meticulously documented, alongside an evaluation of its achievements and
shortcomings. The conclusion of the paper should propose a structured agenda for future
scholarly investigation, prioritising unresolved questions and potential areas for further study to
enhance the understanding and efficacy of such educational transplants.
The Chilean Experiment with School Vouchers: A Critical Examination of a Neoliberal
Educational Transplant from the United States
1. Introduction and Contextual Background
The global landscape of education is characterised by a continuous flow of policies, practices, and
ideologies across national borders. This phenomenon, often termed ‘educational borrowing’ or
‘policy lending’, has become a defining feature of contemporary comparative and international
education. Driven by forces of globalisation, international assessments such as the Programme for
International Student Assessment (PISA), and the agendas of supranational organisations like the
World Bank and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), nations
increasingly look beyond their own borders for solutions to perceived educational crises. However,
the transfer of educational models is not a neutral or straightforward process; it is deeply embedded
in political ideologies, economic imperatives, and cultural values. This essay undertakes an in-depth
exploration and critical examination of one of the most radical and contested educational transplants
of the late twentieth century: the introduction of a nationwide school voucher system in Chile, a
policy model borrowed from the United States.
The significance of this topic lies in its embodiment of pure neoliberal ideology applied to education.
In the early 1980s, the military dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet, advised by a group of
Chilean economists trained at the University of Chicago (the ‘Chicago Boys’), enacted a sweeping
decentralisation reform that included the establishment of a universal school voucher system. This
model was explicitly inspired by the work of American economist Milton Friedman, who first
proposed educational vouchers in his 1955 essay “The Role of Government in Education.” The
Chilean case offers a unique longitudinal laboratory: it is the oldest and most extensive national
voucher system in the world, now spanning over four decades. By examining the transfer of this
policy from its theoretical origins in the US to its brutal implementation in Pinochet’s Chile, this
essay will provide a comprehensive justification for its adoption, delineate the modifications made to
the model, analyse the challenges of implementation and local resistance, document local
perceptions, evaluate its successes and failures, and finally propose a structured agenda for future
scholarly investigation.
